Web Design & Development
Sitewide Search: Learning What Visitors Couldn't Find
The challenge
adroll.com had no sitewide search. That left two problems: visitors who knew what they wanted but not where it lived had only the navigation (and on mobile, search is how many people navigate), and we had no way to see what visitors looked for and found, looked for and didn’t find, or found and didn’t click.
Every failed search is a visitor telling you, in their own words, what you haven’t published or what can’t be found. That information was never being collected.
Nobody asked me to fix this. I spotted it while working on other marketing site needs. I was supporting the marketing department’s web needs, and I wove this experimental work in between their requests for web updates.
The approach
Start with what already worked. Our CMS had a native Algolia integration, and it was already performing well on the blog. Expanding it was the lowest-risk way to get sitewide search before committing real resources.
Index what people look for. I audited the site and mapped in blog posts, resource hubs, product pages, news, webinars, case studies, and the glossary. I left out landing pages and SEM-specific tracks, which are built for campaigns and would have crowded results. Inclusion is managed entry by entry in the CMS, so the content and SEO teams can run it without a developer.
Design every state. The search interface has three, and I designed the layout of each.



Read the logs. Analytics only work if someone is reading them. Analyzed search data to identify content gaps and high-intent demand. Weekly reporting was planned but not shared before the layoff.
Reading the logs also turned up a bug. The search input was appending a trailing space to over 90% of queries, so Algolia treated "remarketing " and “remarketing” as different searches: the clean term returned roughly 25 times as many results as the spaced one, which also broke our synonyms and split the analytics. I wrote it up in a January 2026 report, and with Gemini’s help fixed it by trimming the query before it reaches Algolia.
The result
9,706 searches over 13 weeks (Mar 27 to Jun 24, 2026), from the raw Algolia exports:
- First-party search data the company didn’t have before.
- 46% of searches were empty queries, the default state. Nearly half of all search activity happened on the screen I designed before anyone typed.
- 95% of empty-state search clicks landed in the top six curated results.
- 1.4% of searches returned no results.
- Fixed a trailing-space bug that was causing analytics issues.
- Hundreds of distinct queries returned results but got no clicks. That’s the content-gap signal ready to share.
A query that’s searched often and never clicked is demand already proven against content that’s missing or can’t be found. Counts per query were modest, so I read them for patterns:
- Brand unification: searched often, plenty of results returned, zero clicks, and no dedicated page.
- Programmatic spend forecasts: repeated searches across several phrasings, results returned, no clicks. Visitors wanted a forecast we didn’t have.
- Developers: “developers” and “tech.adroll.com” returned nothing, and “api” returned only a handful of results. That’s a developer audience with no entry point.
- Intent mismatches: “D2C” returned plenty of results and no clicks, because the acronym didn’t match how our content was written. A customer case study got no clicks even when searched by its own name.
It also pointed the other way. Several queries that were searched repeatedly had a 100% click-through rate, including “contextual ad targeting” and “demand side platform”, which marked content strong enough to promote elsewhere.
The next steps
Where I planned to take it:
- Finish the reporting. Share the search findings in a regular report.
- Broaden what’s searchable. Index more content per entry so results match what visitors expect. Each page type stores its content differently.
- Keep tuning synonyms. Keep matching the words visitors use interchangeably, like ctv, connected tv, and ott, or abm and account-based marketing.
- Optimize the rest of Algolia. Check the six curated links against how each page performs, and add rules for high-intent queries that dead-end today, like routing “competitors” to a customer story.